It was praised upon release, but in hindsight Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy has aged into a very impressive cinematic achievement. That Jackson, at the time a low-budget genre auteur from New Zealand, cut through the Weinstein Company shenanigans to deliver a hand-crafted, practically-driven adaptation of a literary classic and managed to spin three great films out of it is remarkable. There’s only a handful of perfect film trilogies where there isn’t a weak installment; The Godfather: Part III is the embarrassment in Francis Ford Coppola’s Mario Puzo adaptations, and even the biggest Star Wars fans can admit that Return of the Jedi is a downgrade from the first two installments. Jackson shot three films at once, which was then an anomaly, and incited general audience enthusiasm for the difficult genre of high fantasy.
What’s remained most staggering about Jackson’s films is how well they have aged. The grueling efforts of shooting on location, designing countless costumes and sets, and using as many practical effects as possible is a handcrafted, detailed aesthetic that hasn’t been rendered obsolete by visual advances. Tolkien fans prickly, and they weren’t uniformly happy with Jackson’s work. However, concerns that Jackson had in some way neutered the original text have mollified over the years based on how many similarly ambitious fantasy adaptations have failed; this would include subsequent efforts to do Tolkien. While not the disasters that some proclaimed them to be, the three The Hobbit films directed by Jackson have left no cultural footprints, despite the presence of many of his The Lord of the Rings collaborators.
A quirk of licensing resulted in Warner Bros. retaining the rights to The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, but not owning Tolkien’s Legendarium outright. This allowed Amazon Studios to strike a deal with the late author’s legal body to develop a five-season prequel series set before the events of both The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, even if it couldn’t directly adapt either novels or technically be considered in-continuity with Jackson’s two trilogies. The only material Amazon had to work with was a timeline of events within Middle-earth history that was listed in the appendices of Tolkien’s third novel. Although Tolkien later wrote another novel, The Silmarillion, that fleshed out these prequel stories in more detail, Amazon was forced to ignore it due to legal stipulations with Warner Bros.
This is useful information in understanding why Amazon’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power has incited fury among Tolkien purists and become a cash-funnel for Prime Video. The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit are set during an era in Tolkien’s universe called the “Third Age,” which detailed the ultimate battle between good and evil between the Dark Lord Sauron and a collective of humans, dwarves, and elves. Tolkien was a World War I veteran who drew on his experiences to develop a story about heroism in the face of unprecedented barbarism, but he also worked in a multitude of religious and historical allusions to Arthurian mythology and Beowulf to William Morris and Robert Wagner. Tolkien’s legendarium is vast, and includes maps, languages, poetry, family trees, and historical records. Yet, The Lord of the Rings is also a classical adventure story with memorable characters and vivid imagination, which is why it appeals to 12-year-olds as well as academics.
•••To create a prequel, especially one that’s not explicitly documented, is to deny narrative stakes because events are already set in place. That’s not to say that prequels can’t be good (Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me and the modern Planet of the Apes trilogy prove that), but that they must either strongly appeal to those already invested or provide a new element exciting enough to spawn a new fanbase. The Rings of Power doesn’t do that. It’s legally prohibited from being faithful to the complexity of Tolkien’s studies, and the writers have shown ignorance in their understanding of the philosophical meaning of the text. Yet, it’s also a story that’s designed to lead into the more compelling tale of The Lord of the Rings; this means it’s catered to an audience that it has taken every turn to irritate with its illiteracy.
It might seem unfair to constantly compare The Rings of Power with Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings, but the show is designed to evoke his style that they can’t help but be contrasted. Amazon paid approximately $1 billion for a five-season commitment, meaning that it’d be a bigger loss to cancel The Rings of Power than it would be to continue churning out episodes. It looks expensive, but that’s no longer a distinguishing factor when every streaming show of this size is costly and aesthetically flat; greenscreen can’t match the beauty of Jackson’s natural locations, which did as much for New Zealand tourism as they did for the Tolkien estate. The issue is made more glaring because of the opening scene of Jackson’s first film, The Fellowship of the Ring, which details the height of the “Second Age,” which is the same era depicted in The Rings of Power.
The third season of The Rings of Power, airing now, is a conscious reset that’s done away with the goofy Hobbit characters in favor of more death and destruction. Perhaps this was made to appease critics and project a tone of seriousness, but the misinterpretation of key Tolkien characters has revealed the surface-level reading. Galadriel, the ethereal Elven royal portrayed by Cate Blanchett in the films, is turned into a badass warrior princess defined by physical prowess. Isildur, Tolkien’s tragic human king corrupted by the power of evil, is framed as a sullen rebellious teenager who was always a bad apple.
Tolkien specifically created the antagonist Sauron as an embodiment of evil so elemental that his human form was hidden by shadow, but The Rings of Power has him as a handsome, maniacal factor in a love triangle with Galadriel and her husband. The Rings of Power’s introduction of the wizard Gandalf ignores Tolkien’s notion of the character as part of a triumvirate; The Lord of the Rings’ three main heroes of Frodo, Aragorn, and Gandalf were modeled after the Christian idea of the priest, the prophet, and the king.
I won’t claim to be completely versed in Tolkien mythology. I also won’t claim that The Rings of Power is unwatchable; the melodrama is diverting, the worldbuilding was done with care, and many of the performances are strong, such as Robert Aramayo’s take on Elrond, a character played by Hugo Weaving in the films. Yet, it’s obvious this project was greenlit because someone thought that it was a good idea to make a The Lord of the Rings show, and not because there was a specific pitch of how to do it.
