Splicetoday

Moving Pictures
Nov 19, 2026, 06:28AM

Body Heat Reverses Double Indemnity

In neo-noir the femme fatale is allowed to win.

30 minutes on body heat.jpg?ixlib=rails 2.1

Lawrence Kasdan’s 1981 Body Heat is often discussed as a remake of Billy Wilder’s classic 1944 domestic adultery noir Double Indemnity. Kasdan’s film, though, is better seen in many ways as a damp, steamy, dialectical reversal of Wilder’s clean-angled ode to a patriarchal order first challenged and then, inevitably, restored. In the original, the femme fatale’s seductive charms tempt a good man off the straight and narrow, but he inevitably finds his way to virtuous confession and revenge. In Body Heat the man isn’t good or righteous, and he doesn’t triumph.

The not-so-good man in question is Ned Racine (William Hurt), a mediocre attorney in a south Florida backwater, following his vices and libido through the damp, humid summer, and into the damp, humid embrace of not-so-happily-married wealthy blonde bombshell Matty Walker (Kathleen Turner, in her screen debut). After Ned smashes a window in a manly apotheosis of manliness and lust, he and Matty engage in steamy right-on-the-border-of-X-rated relations and witty repartee. The most telling exchange of the latter occurs when Matty asks Ned, “You’re not too smart, are you?” When he agrees he isn’t, she chuckles throatily, “I like that in a man.”

Ned says he’s not smart, but he thinks he is. When Matty tells him she inherits half of her husband’s vast fortune and that she wishes the husband would die, Ned comes up with a tricky scheme involving trips to Miami for alibis and arson for body disposal. Ned thinks he’s playing the Fred MacMurray role in Double Indemnity—strong and straight, covering all the exits, leading the plan while the woman admires his manly strength, and/or licks her lips at the bloody results.

But no sooner than the deed is done than the not-smart Ned starts to realize that maybe he’s not the one at the helm. Matty suddenly produces a second will which she claims that Ned helped her husband write, and Ned has to play along, even when the gambit is that he was so incompetent the will’s invalid. Hubby’s glasses, which Matty was supposed to take care of, turn out unburned, tipping the police off that he wasn’t killed where he should have been.

Ned’s male friends—the tap-dancing good-hearted DA Peter Lowenstein (Ted Danson), the good-hearted bomb-maker Teddy (Mickey Rourke) who Ned helped keep out of prison, the good-hearted cop on the case Oscar (J.A. Preston)—all try to save him from the sticky, enveloping, folds of Matty’s influence. But to no avail. The patriarchy’s helpless before a few glimpses of Kathleen Turner topless.

Pauline Kael sneered at Turner for lacking the gravitas of classic femme fatales like Barbara Stanwyck and dinged her for sounding like a “soap-opera actress.” But I think what Kael misses is that the glimpses we see of the true, malevolent Phyllis in Stanwyck’s portrayal are also signs of Phyllis’ weakness. She doesn’t have full control over her mask, and that leads to her downfall.

Matty, though, after the initial fencing wordplay, is all breathy declarations of love and limpid clinging because that’s what she knows Ned wants her to be—and because the film knows that’s what the male viewers want. Even when Ned has her dead to rights, even when he has proof positive that she’s trying to kill him and even when she knows he knows he has proof positive, she never breaks character, never stops emoting in those deep, musical tones, her blonde hair swaying, her thigh flashing from her slit white dress. “I love you. You’ve got to believe me!” And poor Ned bites back, “Keep talking, Matty. Experience shows I can be convinced of anything.” And then, one last time, she convinces him of everything.

There are examples of the femme fatale getting away with the cash and with murder in noir novels from the classic period—Charles Williams’ A Touch of Death, as one example. It almost never happened in film though, where the Code insisted all villains had to be punished and the patriarchal order restored by the end of the run time. Women couldn’t get the upper hand; no feminism allowed.

Matty’s victory isn’t a feminist triumph. The movie’s always from Ned’s point of view, and you, like his male buddies, sympathize with his desire, bafflement and downfall; Matty’s relentlessness, and her perfect front, make her inhuman and unknowable. And while Kasdan suggests that Ned’s weak, foolish and amoral, he never really makes Ned unlikable, or gives Matty a reason for turning on him. Or, at least, when he does (as in a scene in which Ned and Peter make crude jokes about Matty’s young niece) it’s unclear that you’re supposed to think less of him. Kasdan, in that sense, is part of the patriarchal collaboration in ignorance and entitlement. As far as the men are concerned, Matty has no reason for destroying Ned’s life; she’s just greedy and ambitious and never cared for him, however enthusiastic she seems in those love scenes. She castrates him casually; it’s nothing personal.

The victorious femme fatale, though, opened the door for more thoroughgoing questioning of the patriarchal verities. Movies like Basic Instinct (1992), The Last Seduction (1994) or Wild Things (1998) use the Body Heat blueprint to edge on into feministploitation. In those movies, you’re at least partially on the side of the femme fatale, rooting for her to finish off abusive, entitled guys who are bamboozled by their crude assumption that they must be in control and on top.

Classic noir on film flirted with the idea of powerful women wreaking havoc on virtue and order; Body Heat begins a long, damp neo-noir slide into ever more sticky and heated vagina dentatas. Charming, disheveled, incompetent Ned jumps onto the slope convinced his manliness will steer him well. But it turns out he’s in a different, wetter, and hotter kind of film.

Discussion

Register or Login to leave a comment